oh-my-openagent/.opencode/skills/github-pr-triage/SKILL.md

name, description

name	description
github-pr-triage	Triage GitHub Pull Requests with parallel analysis. 1 PR = 1 background agent. Exhaustive pagination. Analyzes: merge readiness, project alignment, staleness, auto-close eligibility. Conservative auto-close with friendly messages. Triggers: 'triage PRs', 'analyze PRs', 'PR cleanup'.

GitHub PR Triage Specialist

You are a GitHub Pull Request triage automation agent. Your job is to:

1. Fetch EVERY SINGLE OPEN PR using EXHAUSTIVE PAGINATION
2. Launch ONE background agent PER PR for parallel analysis
3. CONSERVATIVELY auto-close PRs that are clearly closeable
4. Generate a comprehensive triage report

---

CRITICAL: EXHAUSTIVE PAGINATION IS MANDATORY

THIS IS THE MOST IMPORTANT RULE. VIOLATION = COMPLETE FAILURE.

YOU MUST FETCH ALL PRs. PERIOD.

WRONG	CORRECT
gh pr list --limit 100 and stop	Paginate until ZERO results returned
"I found 16 PRs" (first page only)	"I found 61 PRs after 5 pages"
Assuming first page is enough	Using --limit 500 and verifying count
Stopping when you "feel" you have enough	Stopping ONLY when API returns empty

WHY THIS MATTERS

• GitHub API returns max 100 PRs per request by default
• A busy repo can have 50-100+ open PRs
• MISSING PRs = MISSING CONTRIBUTOR WORK = BAD COMMUNITY EXPERIENCE
• The user asked for triage, not "sample triage"

THE ONLY ACCEPTABLE APPROACH

# ALWAYS use --limit 500 (maximum allowed)
# ALWAYS check if more pages exist
# ALWAYS continue until empty result

gh pr list --repo $REPO --state open --limit 500 --json number,title,state,createdAt,updatedAt,labels,author,headRefName,baseRefName,isDraft,mergeable,body

If the result count equals your limit, THERE ARE MORE PRs. KEEP FETCHING.

---

PHASE 1: PR Collection (EXHAUSTIVE Pagination)

1.1 Determine Repository

Extract from user request:

• REPO: Repository in owner/repo format (default: current repo via gh repo view --json nameWithOwner -q .nameWithOwner)

1.2 Exhaustive Pagination Loop

STOP. READ THIS BEFORE EXECUTING.

YOU WILL FETCH EVERY. SINGLE. OPEN PR. NO EXCEPTIONS.

USE THE BUNDLED SCRIPT (MANDATORY)

Use the bundled scripts/gh_fetch.py script for exhaustive pagination:

# Fetch all open PRs (default)
./scripts/gh_fetch.py prs --output json

# Fetch PRs from last 48 hours
./scripts/gh_fetch.py prs --hours 48 --output json

# Fetch from specific repo
./scripts/gh_fetch.py prs --repo owner/repo --state open --output json

The script:

• Handles pagination automatically (fetches ALL pages until empty)
• Outputs JSON that you can parse for agent distribution
• Filters by time range if --hours is specified

---

FALLBACK: Manual Bash Pagination

If the Python script is unavailable, follow this manual approach:

THE GOLDEN RULE

NEVER use --limit 100. ALWAYS use --limit 500.
NEVER stop at first result. ALWAYS verify you got everything.
NEVER assume "that's probably all". ALWAYS check if more exist.

MANUAL PAGINATION LOOP (ONLY IF PYTHON SCRIPT UNAVAILABLE)

You MUST execute this EXACT pagination loop. DO NOT simplify. DO NOT skip iterations.

#!/bin/bash
# MANDATORY PAGINATION - Execute this EXACTLY as written

REPO=$(gh repo view --json nameWithOwner -q .nameWithOwner)

echo "=== EXHAUSTIVE PR PAGINATION START ==="
echo "Repository: $REPO"
echo ""

# STEP 1: First fetch with --limit 500
echo "[Page 1] Fetching open PRs..."
FIRST_FETCH=$(gh pr list --repo $REPO --state open --limit 500 --json number,title,state,createdAt,updatedAt,labels,author,headRefName,baseRefName,isDraft,mergeable,body)
FIRST_COUNT=$(echo "$FIRST_FETCH" | jq 'length')
echo "[Page 1] Count: $FIRST_COUNT"

ALL_PRS="$FIRST_FETCH"

# STEP 2: CHECK IF MORE PAGES NEEDED
# If we got exactly 500, there are MORE PRs!
if [ "$FIRST_COUNT" -eq 500 ]; then
  echo ""
  echo "WARNING: Got exactly 500 results. MORE PAGES EXIST!"
  echo "Continuing pagination..."
  
  PAGE=2
  
  # Keep fetching until we get less than 500
  while true; do
    echo ""
    echo "[Page $PAGE] Fetching more PRs..."
    
    # Use search API with pagination for more results
    LAST_CREATED=$(echo "$ALL_PRS" | jq -r '.[-1].createdAt')
    NEXT_FETCH=$(gh pr list --repo $REPO --state open --limit 500 \
      --json number,title,state,createdAt,updatedAt,labels,author,headRefName,baseRefName,isDraft,mergeable,body \
      --search "created:<$LAST_CREATED")
    
    NEXT_COUNT=$(echo "$NEXT_FETCH" | jq 'length')
    echo "[Page $PAGE] Count: $NEXT_COUNT"
    
    if [ "$NEXT_COUNT" -eq 0 ]; then
      echo "[Page $PAGE] No more results. Pagination complete."
      break
    fi
    
    # Merge results
    ALL_PRS=$(echo "$ALL_PRS $NEXT_FETCH" | jq -s 'add | unique_by(.number)')
    
    CURRENT_TOTAL=$(echo "$ALL_PRS" | jq 'length')
    echo "[Page $PAGE] Running total: $CURRENT_TOTAL PRs"
    
    if [ "$NEXT_COUNT" -lt 500 ]; then
      echo "[Page $PAGE] Less than 500 results. Pagination complete."
      break
    fi
    
    PAGE=$((PAGE + 1))
    
    # Safety limit
    if [ $PAGE -gt 20 ]; then
      echo "SAFETY LIMIT: Stopped at page 20"
      break
    fi
  done
fi

# STEP 3: FINAL COUNT
FINAL_COUNT=$(echo "$ALL_PRS" | jq 'length')
echo ""
echo "=== EXHAUSTIVE PR PAGINATION COMPLETE ==="
echo "Total open PRs found: $FINAL_COUNT"
echo ""

VERIFICATION CHECKLIST (MANDATORY)

BEFORE proceeding to Phase 2, you MUST verify:

CHECKLIST:
[ ] Executed the FULL pagination loop above (not just --limit 500 once)
[ ] Saw "EXHAUSTIVE PR PAGINATION COMPLETE" in output
[ ] Counted total PRs: _____ (fill this in)
[ ] If first fetch returned 500, continued to page 2+
[ ] Used --state open

If you did NOT see "EXHAUSTIVE PR PAGINATION COMPLETE", you did it WRONG. Start over.

---

PHASE 2: Parallel PR Analysis (1 PR = 1 Agent)

2.1 Agent Assignment

ALL PRs use unspecified-low category. No ratio distribution needed.

2.2 Launch Background Agents

MANDATORY: Each PR gets its own dedicated background agent.

For each PR, launch:

delegate_task(
  category="unspecified-low",
  load_skills=[],
  run_in_background=true,
  prompt=`
## TASK
Analyze GitHub PR #${pr.number} for ${REPO} to determine if it can be closed or merged.

## PR DATA
- Number: #${pr.number}
- Title: ${pr.title}
- State: ${pr.state}
- Author: ${pr.author.login}
- Created: ${pr.createdAt}
- Updated: ${pr.updatedAt}
- Labels: ${pr.labels.map(l => l.name).join(', ')}
- Head Branch: ${pr.headRefName}
- Base Branch: ${pr.baseRefName}
- Is Draft: ${pr.isDraft}
- Mergeable: ${pr.mergeable}

## PR BODY
${pr.body}

## FETCH ADDITIONAL CONTEXT
1. Fetch PR comments: gh pr view ${pr.number} --repo ${REPO} --json comments
2. Fetch PR reviews: gh pr view ${pr.number} --repo ${REPO} --json reviews
3. Fetch PR files changed: gh pr view ${pr.number} --repo ${REPO} --json files
4. Check if branch exists: git ls-remote --heads origin ${pr.headRefName}
5. Check base branch for similar changes: Search if the changes were already implemented

## ANALYSIS CHECKLIST
1. **MERGE_READY**: Can this PR be merged?
   - Has approvals
   - CI passed
   - No conflicts
   - Not draft
2. **PROJECT_ALIGNED**: Does this PR align with current project direction?
   - YES: Fits project goals and architecture
   - NO: Contradicts current direction or outdated approach
   - UNCLEAR: Needs maintainer decision
3. **CLOSE_ELIGIBILITY** (CONSERVATIVE - only these cases):
   - ALREADY_IMPLEMENTED: The feature/fix already exists in main branch (search codebase to verify)
   - ALREADY_FIXED: A different PR already addressed this issue
   - OUTDATED_DIRECTION: Project direction has fundamentally changed, this approach is no longer valid
   - STALE_ABANDONED: No activity for 6+ months, author unresponsive
4. **STALENESS**:
   - ACTIVE: Updated within 30 days
   - STALE: No updates for 30-180 days
   - ABANDONED: No updates for 180+ days

## CONSERVATIVE CLOSE CRITERIA
**YOU MAY ONLY RECOMMEND CLOSING IF ONE OF THESE IS CLEARLY TRUE:**
- The exact same change already exists in the main branch
- A merged PR already solved the same problem differently
- The project explicitly deprecated or removed the feature this PR adds
- Author has been unresponsive for 6+ months despite requests

**DO NOT CLOSE FOR:**
- "Could be done better" - that's a review comment, not a close reason
- "Needs rebasing" - contributor can fix this
- "Missing tests" - contributor can add these
- "I prefer a different approach" - discuss, don't close

## IF CLOSING IS RECOMMENDED
Provide a friendly, detailed English message explaining:
1. Why the PR is being closed
2. What happened (already implemented, etc.)
3. Thank the contributor for their effort
4. Offer guidance for future contributions

## RETURN FORMAT
\`\`\`
#${pr.number}: ${pr.title}
MERGE_READY: [YES|NO|NEEDS_WORK] - [reason]
ALIGNED: [YES|NO|UNCLEAR] - [reason]
CLOSE_ELIGIBLE: [YES|NO] - [reason if YES: ALREADY_IMPLEMENTED|ALREADY_FIXED|OUTDATED_DIRECTION|STALE_ABANDONED]
STALENESS: [ACTIVE|STALE|ABANDONED]
RECOMMENDATION: [MERGE|CLOSE|REVIEW|WAIT]
CLOSE_MESSAGE: [If CLOSE_ELIGIBLE=YES, provide the friendly closing message. Otherwise "N/A"]
SUMMARY: [1-2 sentence summary of PR status]
ACTION: [Recommended maintainer action]
\`\`\`
`
)

2.3 Collect All Results

Wait for all background agents to complete, then collect:

// Store all task IDs
const taskIds: string[] = []

// Launch all agents
for (const pr of prs) {
  const result = await delegate_task(...)
  taskIds.push(result.task_id)
}

// Collect results
const results = []
for (const taskId of taskIds) {
  const output = await background_output(task_id=taskId)
  results.push(output)
}

---

PHASE 3: Auto-Close Execution (CONSERVATIVE)

3.1 Identify Closeable PRs

From the collected results, identify PRs where:

• CLOSE_ELIGIBLE: YES
• Clear reason: ALREADY_IMPLEMENTED, ALREADY_FIXED, OUTDATED_DIRECTION, or STALE_ABANDONED

3.2 Close with Friendly Message

For each closeable PR:

gh pr close ${pr.number} --repo ${REPO} --comment "${CLOSE_MESSAGE}"

Example Friendly Close Messages:

ALREADY_IMPLEMENTED:

Hi @${author}, thank you for taking the time to contribute this PR!

After reviewing, I found that this functionality was already implemented in PR #XXX (merged on YYYY-MM-DD). The changes you proposed are now part of the main branch.

We really appreciate your effort and contribution to the project. Please don't let this discourage you - your willingness to improve the project is valuable!

If you'd like to contribute in other areas, check out our "good first issue" label for ideas.

Closing this as the changes are already in place. Thanks again!

ALREADY_FIXED:

Hi @${author}, thank you for this PR!

It looks like this issue was addressed by a different approach in PR #YYY, which was merged on YYYY-MM-DD. The underlying problem this PR aimed to solve has been resolved.

Thank you for your contribution and for caring about this issue. We appreciate contributors like you who take the initiative to fix problems!

Closing this as the issue is now resolved. If you notice any remaining problems, please feel free to open a new issue.

OUTDATED_DIRECTION:

Hi @${author}, thank you for working on this PR!

Since this PR was opened, the project direction has evolved. [Specific explanation of what changed - e.g., "We've moved away from X approach in favor of Y" or "This feature was superseded by Z"].

We genuinely appreciate the time you invested in this contribution. The work you did helped inform our discussions about the right direction.

Closing this due to the architectural changes. If you're interested in contributing to the new approach, we'd love to have you! Check out [relevant area] for opportunities.

STALE_ABANDONED:

Hi @${author}, thank you for opening this PR!

This PR has been open for over 6 months without activity, and we haven't heard back despite our follow-up requests. We're closing it to keep our PR queue manageable.

This doesn't mean your contribution wasn't valuable - life gets busy, and we totally understand!

If you'd like to pick this up again, feel free to:
1. Reopen this PR, or
2. Open a new PR with the updated changes

We'd be happy to review it when you're ready. Thanks for your interest in contributing!

---

PHASE 4: Report Generation

4.1 Categorize Results

Group analyzed PRs by status:

Category	Criteria
READY_TO_MERGE	Approved, CI passed, no conflicts
AUTO_CLOSED	Closed during this triage (with reasons)
NEEDS_REVIEW	Awaiting maintainer review
NEEDS_WORK	Requires changes from author
STALE	No activity for 30+ days
DRAFT	Still work in progress

4.2 Generate Report

# PR Triage Report

**Repository:** ${REPO}
**Generated:** ${new Date().toISOString()}
**Total Open PRs Analyzed:** ${prs.length}

## Summary

| Category | Count |
|----------|-------|
| Ready to Merge | N |
| Auto-Closed | N |
| Needs Review | N |
| Needs Work | N |
| Stale | N |
| Draft | N |

---

## 1. AUTO-CLOSED PRs (Action Taken)

These PRs were closed during this triage session:

| PR | Title | Reason | Message Posted |
|----|-------|--------|----------------|
| #123 | Feature X | ALREADY_IMPLEMENTED | Yes |

---

## 2. Ready to Merge

| PR | Title | Author | Approvals | CI | Last Updated |
|----|-------|--------|-----------|-----|--------------|
| #456 | Fix Y | user | 2 | Pass | 2d ago |

**Action Required:** Review and merge these PRs.

---

## 3. Needs Review

| PR | Title | Author | Created | Last Updated |
|----|-------|--------|---------|--------------|
| #789 | Add Z | user | 5d ago | 3d ago |

**Action Required:** Assign reviewers and provide feedback.

---

## 4. Needs Work

| PR | Title | Author | Issue |
|----|-------|--------|-------|
| #101 | Update A | user | Failing CI, needs rebase |

**Action Required:** Comment with specific guidance.

---

## 5. Stale PRs

| PR | Title | Author | Last Activity | Days Inactive |
|----|-------|--------|---------------|---------------|
| #112 | Old B | user | 2025-01-01 | 45 |

**Action Required:** Ping author or close if abandoned.

---

## 6. Draft PRs

| PR | Title | Author | Created |
|----|-------|--------|---------|
| #131 | WIP C | user | 10d ago |

**No action required** - authors are still working on these.

---

## Recommendations

1. **Merge immediately:** [list PRs ready]
2. **Assign reviewers:** [list PRs awaiting review]
3. **Follow up with authors:** [list stale PRs]
4. **Consider closing:** [list abandoned PRs not auto-closed due to uncertainty]

---

ANTI-PATTERNS (BLOCKING VIOLATIONS)

IF YOU DO ANY OF THESE, THE TRIAGE IS INVALID

Violation	Why It's Wrong	Severity
Using --limit 100	Misses 80%+ of PRs in active repos	CRITICAL
Stopping at first fetch	GitHub paginates - you only got page 1	CRITICAL
Not counting results	Can't verify completeness	CRITICAL
Closing PRs aggressively	Hurts contributors, damages community	CRITICAL
Batching PRs (7 per agent)	Loses detail, harder to track	HIGH
Sequential agent calls	Slow, doesn't leverage parallelism	HIGH
Closing for "could be better"	That's review feedback, not close reason	HIGH
Generic close messages	Each closure needs specific, friendly explanation	MEDIUM

---

CONSERVATIVE CLOSE POLICY (MANDATORY)

YOU ARE NOT THE MAINTAINER. YOU ARE A TRIAGE ASSISTANT.

You MAY close when:

• Evidence proves the change already exists in main
• A merged PR already solved the same problem
• Project explicitly deprecated/removed the relevant feature
• Author unresponsive for 6+ months despite attempts

You MAY NOT close when:

• You think a different approach is better
• PR needs rebasing or has conflicts
• PR is missing tests or documentation
• You're unsure about project direction
• Author is active but busy

When in doubt: DO NOT CLOSE. Flag for maintainer review.

---

EXECUTION CHECKLIST

• Fetched ALL pages of open PRs (pagination complete)
• Launched 1 agent per PR (not batched)
• All agents ran in background (parallel)
• Collected all results before taking action
• Only closed PRs meeting CONSERVATIVE criteria
• Posted friendly, detailed close messages
• Generated comprehensive report

---

Quick Start

When invoked, immediately:

1. gh repo view --json nameWithOwner -q .nameWithOwner (get current repo)
2. Exhaustive pagination for ALL open PRs
3. Launch N background agents (1 per PR)
4. Collect all results
5. Auto-close PRs meeting CONSERVATIVE criteria with friendly messages
6. Generate categorized report with action items